TV Shows that needed Spankings

Wheatwine: I think that despite her brattiness and youth (and 'no' I don't want to sound like some creepy pedophile or anything) "Sam" is a definte Top in the making. Let nature take its course. While seeing a brat get their comeuppance is always fun, there is also something edgy about certain Toppy/bratty girls ending up as the ones inevitably in control. I personally would rather see the two other characters, Carly and the boy who helps them, end up spanked by Sam.........even if they don't deserve it and she does merely by virtue of her dominance and their more passive personalities. That's what makes power dynamics fun.

As I stated earlier in this thread, IMHO there are some fictional heroines that I'd consider 100% 'toppish'--however, there are some male heroes that I'd likewise think of as also 100% 'toppish.'

However, as in the discussion of Xena and later this character (Samantha), I do often read proposals or speculation RE how these 'toppish' female heroines could somehow nonetheless be "put in their place" by being spanked (often forcibly and nonconsensually), and it makes me wonder if there are people who don't like the concept of independent, assertive, indomitable women even in fiction/fantasy.

Even though my spanking gender orientation is basically F/M, there are male fictional heroes whom I'd consider totally 'toppish' and I don't imagine them being spanked by anyone (except possibly their mothers)--Captain Jean-Luc Picard ("Star Trek: The Next Generation"), Hercules, Batman, Commander Adama ("Battlestar Galactica" #2), Angel, General Martok ("Star Trek: Deep Space Nine"), etc. I don't remember ever reading any speculation RE how apparently 'toppish' fictional males could somehow end up being spanked in some fanfiction fantasy scenarios, yet I do recall reading numerous proposals about how their equally 'toppish' feminine counterparts could end up across the knee of some guy--for example, the suggestion that Samantha could be paddled by an NFL defensive lineman. Has anyone ever suggested how super-powerful Clark Kent ("Smallville") could end up on the receiving end of a good buttwhacking? (I don't remember any, even though IMHO his personality isn't all that 'toppish.')

However, I would agree that--as proposed with Xena earlier in this thread--even 'toppish' fictional types might plausibly be given maternal or quasi-maternal spankings, especially if they actually requested those punishments or at least readily accepted them. (I do personally feel this type of fantasy situation more likely to occur with females than males, the heroines strike me as being somewhat more willing to accept maternal-style guidance and correction even as powerful adults--it probably has something to do with the lasting complexities of mother-daughter relationships.)

AFAIC some fictional characters, both female and male, aren't plausibly meant to be spanked, and--with the possible occasional exception of maternal-type chastisements--don't work well as spankees, even in fantasy. --C.K.

P.S.: If an author point-blank needs a current NFL defensive lineman as a physically strong spanker, I'd suggest Ndamukong Suh of the Detroit Lions.

I could definitely see Jean-Luc spanking his very bratty, sometimes paramour, Vosh.

Here's a not so original thought. One Day at a Time. Valerie Bertinelli. Over her mother's knee. Bare bottom. And a hairbrush

There was a scene on one of the later episodes, involving the boy that was living in the apartment (I forget if either daughter was stilling there but it would have been Phillips left the show) where Ann used either a hairbrush or a paddle. And there was that scene where Ann slapped Philips' character on the face...

But yes, I would have loved to see Valerie Bartinelli spanked that way.

Goodgulf

Yes indeed, Ms. Bertinelli's young-teenaged character (Barbara?) struck me as very 'bottomish' (as well as showing off a highly spankable posterior in those tight bluejeans) in "One Day at a Time," I've read numerous fanfiction proposals RE her bare bottom being soundly walloped with a hairbrush, paddle and/or belt--I likewise agree that her mother Ann Romano (played by Bonnie Franklin) would've been the ideal person to blister that saucy teenage derriere.

So who's going to write that story for us?

"Which of us is going to attach that bell to the cat's collar?" --C.K.

Smallville there was a scene where Clark and Lana were nearly busted in bed together. It never happened, but I always imagined the gorgeous Ms Kreuk being soundly spanked over Mrs Kent's knee before Jonathan escorted her to the woodshed for an encounter with his strap.

Finally. A series I recognize. I guess I haven't watched much TV in the past couple decades. I certainly do agree with the sentiment of of having Ms. Bertinelli get it, however - but today, even.

CrimsonKidck made a good point about maybe some not liking strong, assertive women and wanting to see them "put in their place" by a strong nonconsensual spanking administered by a male. Afraid that might be true in some cases. However, I can say its something I do not care for. If a so-called "Toppy" woman like Xena gets spanked, let it be by another female, not a story where once again male dominance prevails.
The attitude that the only "natural" or "normal" spanking relationship is M/F is one that is out there. I've come across it on a couple sites, where it is implied that F/M, for example, is contrary to the natural order of biologically-determined male dominance and female submission. And further implied is that same-sex relationships,spanking or not, fall into the same category.
Saying that ALL males are dominant and ALL females submissive is simply a widesweeping generalization that I do not think can be supported by facts.
Just because something is not turn-on or interest to one'self does not mean it is bad, or that those it does appeal to are wrong. I personally prefer reading M/F and F/F stories, but I would never say that people who like to read or write F/M or M/M shouldn't do so.

Enlighten me if my memory's faulty, but wasn't Clark willing to have a sexual relationship with Lana only while he'd lost his super powers and was therefore vulnerable with only human-level strength? IIRC, once he'd regained his abilities, including his super strength, he was afraid of seriously hurting her in a moment of not-fully-controlled passion and therefore dodged any further sexual intimacy.

So if Martha and Jonathan Kent were actually inclined to be judgemental about the sexual behavior of young adults, wouldn't they hold Clark, their own son, as at least equally accountable for any 'rolling in the hay' along with Lana? Therefore wouldn't both of the young lovers be corporally corrected (assuming that both Clark and Lana agreed to accept such discipline) rather than only Lana being spanked and strapped?

Of course if Clark did possess his Kryptonian vulnerability at that point then he couldn't be effectively punished physically, but IMHO that would be a terrible injustice that only Lana ended up 'facing the music' in terms of her sweet derriere being seriously reddened. (Not that unfairness would necessarily disqualify any particular story line, sometimes it can be diabolically delicious.)

Clark would certainly have been racked with regret had Lana accepted severe corporal correction from his parents that he couldn't experience himself, in that sense he'd certainly punish himself emotionally to an extreme degree--he seemed to have a lot of guilt issues anyway, except when it came to his failure to be that good of a friend to Lex Luthor in "Smallville's" first 4-5 seasons..

I must admit that a story about Martha OTK paddling Lana's sexy bare bottom does have a certain appeal--I've always thought that she (Martha) would be a high effective fantasy spanker... --C.K.