How much description to include is a tricky and very individual decision for a writer. I find some stories too bare for my taste, some over filled with irrelevant descriptions. In some cases a detailed description of a character can illuminate the reader's impression of that character, and perhaps even more, can resonate with the reaction other characters have to the character being described. Then again, some writers have lush, poetic and colorful descriptions of the physical landscape (Jack Vance comes particularly to mind) while others have very spare, almost kabuki-like stage settings (Isaac Asimov comes to mind), and both work very well indeed.
AS for what bores me, mundane quotidian conversation that neither advances the plot, nor illuminates the characters or setting. Also, what Damon Knight called "False realism" -- the minute description of unimportant action. He cited as particularly common (this was a good many years ago) detai led description of the manner in which a character smoked a cigarette. Perhaps the most extreme version of this was in one of the notoriously padded Badger line of SF where some 10 pages are spent on the heroine brushing her teeth.
Oh and as to poker games and the like, a detailed description of a bridge game was essential to Agatha Christie's _Cards on the Table_ and a somewhat detailed description of a Mah Jong game was at least helpful to her _Murder of Roger Ackroyd_. And what would _Rounders_ have been without the detailed Poker scenes?
But then to any rules about "good writing" you can find an exception. I love the story of of the Lit professor who told his class "Form the very start of your book, you must make your characters LIVE. Your rader must feel taht they are vibrant and full of life" when a voice from the back of the room called out, "To begin with, Marley was dead." (which is of course the opening line of _A Christmas Carol_)
In a spanking story, i often like detailed physical descriptions of the spanking, although some of the best have lite or none of this. Emotional and relationship setups can be very enjoyable, but when they are poorly done and predictable, they can get very boring.
And as was said above, everyone's taste will differ in such matters.
-Don L. |