Request: Ideas for Mistaken Identity / Mistaken for Being Younger Scenarios

The mistaken identity issue forms the first part of my recent 'Miss Ann Smyth's first day' when first one of the mistresses and then the headmaster mistake Ann(abel), a new teacher in her early twenties on her first day, for Anne a new sixth former also on her first day which results in be being punished for walking on the grass in contravention of the rules.

Redskinluver "Don't recall the name of it, but understand there was an old movie, where woman gets mistaken for her younger sister who is in a college sorority, and gets paddled by the sorority sisters."

I don't know if this is what you were thinking about or not...But there was an old sit-com in the late 50s called I Married Joan in which that exact scenario makes up an episode
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-lplYFr9JcU&t=688s

imreadonly2 I look forward to seeing your story in print, it seems a great idea. Anyone observing DMackenzie being led by the security guard (I am hoping he was an older chap) might have jumped to their own conclusions about what was going on.

I quite enjoyed Ann Smyth's first day. It's especially delicious when a young woman is treated like a child for something that is barely a misdemeanor for an adult, like walking on the grass. I also love people getting spanked like children because of trivial, bureaucratic mistakes, like a mixup with the names. It was a splendid story!

I did send DMackenzie a few snippets, but not sure if she's interested. In any event, I'm so glad she posted, as it is a wonderful setup for a story!

Have you seen the TV show "Warehouse 13?"
An artifact like the artifacts the characters are always trying to find and neutralize presents some very interesting possibilities.

Friday the 13th: The Series was like that. An antiques store was full of cursed items that were accidentally sold. The plot had a pair of cousin and their uncle's old business partner (from before the Uncle made a deal with hell) trying to track down all of the cursed items.

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friday_the_13th:_The_Series for more information

Could I see a cursed paddle, strap, punishment chair, dress, etc? Yes, I could. Louise Robey had a very, very spankable rump. It was never spanked (darn it) but it could happen in fanfic.

I know that I have at least one (possibly more than one) story involving a haunted spanking. It's called "The Haunting", is mother / son, and the paddle gives a dream spanking when the son doesn't get a spanking that he's "earned".

1976, When i was 17 i was a school prefect, 4 of us were on duty at lunch time, together with a new rather lovely lady teacher, presumably newly qualified. The Dep head was a right old bastard and he loved any excuse to get his slipper into action. The lunch break was not going well, younger children were charging about the corridors and frankly we couldnt have cared less......nobody wanted to be a prefect. Then the dep head appeared, in a few minutes he had cleared the building and he called us all to his office. The 5 of us, including her, stood being berated and he announced the 3 boys would get the slipper from him, the two girls would report to Mrs J, head of girls....who also wielded her own slipper. Of they went with a note. We each got whacked....it bloody hurt! Then afterwards we found both the girls rubbing slippered bottoms, both had a few tears and said they had 3 whacks each.
We asked Miss P why she didnt just say she was a member of staff, she explained that she realised she looked like us, 6th formers did not wear uniforms, and she decided better to get a few whacks than have her inadequacies as a teacher controlling prefects and students exposed, as she was new and trying to create a good impression.
She swore us to secrecy and we didnt mention it again.
I did note that in future she wore much more adult and professional clothes to school.
I had a massive crush on her and often imagined smacking her sexy little bottom while she lay over my lap.
Sadly that dream never materialised, but the whole episode was a step in the right direction, and i have spanked many naughty girls bottoms over the years!

That is a good idea for a story.

Indeed it is a lovely idea for a story.
I rather like the thought that the deputy head did in fact know she was a teacher but liked the thought of her getting punished anyway.

Ah 'mistaken identity'. This is another of those scenarios that seem so popular that I just can't get into. However, that said, since this old thread seems to have found new life, I tried to think of a scenario that would actually appeal to me and while I have no intention of writing a piece like this, I offer it up to anyone who wants to give it a try.

To make the idea fresh and appealing I have added one crucial element usually absent from these stories: complicit intent. What I would not mind reading would be a story where the curious submissive character (of whatever gender, since I see no reason why women always seem to have to be the ones being mistaken for a younger person...........and how refreshing would it be for the character to be male for a change?) wants to experience the thrill of being spanked in a situation where they are treated like a minor so that they are not in a position to back out. This character intentionally exaggerates their perhaps already youthful look for one even younger and then place themselves in some sort of punitive jeopardy in some setting where minors are typically punished.

What I would then like to see is their plan work......long enough to have them punished....but then discovered, so that they are now found out as an adult and now facing serious consequences for their perceived as perverted deception. They do eventually get bailed out by a responsible spouse/partner/friend/whatever who persuades the offended party from pursuing charges and then decides that the caper is worthy of further punishment from them......thereby giving the sub character a double dose of inescapable punishment.

I don't think such a story has been done, so if it works for you feel free to use it and make it your own.