GG, I think it is too facile to blame the mores of the times. We (or at least I) are not talking of spankings in novels, there have always been many of them and there continue to be, but spanking novels, ie, books built around spankings or spankers in the way that the GOR books are built around the concept of female slavery or 9 1/2 weeks is built around D/S. This, with the McIver exception and the Good Colonel's citation of Edith Cadivec (which I am only vaguely aware of since female spankers are not my obsession) does not seem to exist. Neither is the sensitivity towards spankings in romances really an artifact of the 80's, every Harlequin ever written leads up to a climatic scene in which the heroine should be spanked, virtually none of them contain the scene and its appearance was rarer in the sixties and seventies than since. My theory, for free, on the sensitivity towards spanking scenes is that it stems from a fairly wide-spread excitement about spanking, not perhaps to the degree it appears among the patrons of the Library, but definite nonetheless. Thus the reader, and perhaps more importantly the publisher, can dismiss the pony girls in the Beauty trilogy as one of the odd erotic things THEY like, spankings are much closer to one of the odd erotic things WE like. Much harder to deal with. |