Is it genetic?

This could be an interesting development.

Frankly, I think it's genetic. Why, besides all the R/L stories I've heard concerning differing generations, simple: In college, way before the net was a common thing, searched for a Disciplinarian in CP periodicals that contained personal ads. In one, found an ad from my Maternal One. 'nough said!

Nope. I would find me smacking her rear to be incredibly inappropriate. I think her bottom should only be smacked by whoever she eventually settles down with.

I presume you did not pay her a visit, but imagine how embarrassed she would have been if you had done. Or maybe she might just have been irate and you might have got a freebie. The possibilities for a story are endless. Thanks for sharing.

I agree. Spanking for me has strong sexual overtones, so spanking my own daughter would seem like incest.

From what you have told us, it sounds as if she might be the one doing the spanking.

I can't speak for you or anyone else, but I will say that had the same thing happened to me, it would have changed my life somewhat substantially.

I only ever spanked two of my daughters, once and at the same time, for doing something beyond the pail/pale.
Is it genetic?
I'm not sure if any of my daughters have it, but when moving my son a few years ago, I did find a table-tennis bat and a leather paddle in a box under his bed. I have never broached the subject with him............

Well, she seems to have become quite competent in that field already I must say. It stung pretty good

For those that don't follow her already, Jillian Keenan has recently released a couple of interesting videos on the topic of where spanking fetishes come from (https://youtu.be/D3xdXj0acZo; https://youtu.be/z43rbt3Zk2A). Not exactly an answer to your question Glagla, but somewhat related, and very interesting and worthwhile nonetheless.

BashfulBob
We had a couple of discussions and during the last one the Maternal One stated she'd "grown-up" and din't pursue it anymore. Is anyone else pushing a bridge for sale?