galt54:
I guess I am turned on by the thought of the "stronger" male dominating the "weaker" female for the sake of his own, but also the female“s, happiness. I suppose that I like to think that *both* the spanker and the spankee benefit from the act.
Well, as I stated in another thread, I prefer in reading (and tend to portray in writing) that any longstanding marital/romantic spanking relationship benefits both partners, albeit in different ways if it's one-sided--that's for ALL gender combinations (M/F, F/M, F/F & M/M).
I consider "strong" to be a psychological more than a physical description of the dominant partner in a spanking relationship in modern times (when a nonconsensual husband/wife bottom-warming is legally categorized as spousal abuse), although I don't believe that overall psychological "strength" is necessarily involved in such a mutually-accepted arrangement between adults. Sometimes a spanking relationship (marital, romantic, family-based or even friendship-oriented) simply works better with one person on the receiving end of chastisements (disciplinary and/or erotic and/or playful) and the other one wielding the seat-stinging implement(s), even though in overall "strength" of psyche they may be roughly equal or the spanker may even be "weaker." (I'm figuring this to be true in both RL situations and in fictional ones.)
I don't read historical romances (other than GONE WITH THE WIND) but my sweet spouse does, and she's told me that they occasionally include M/F spanking scenes in which the "stronger" (both physically and psychologically) male hero bends the "weaker" female protagonist to his will (as well as over his knee) and "tames" the woman "for her own good" (as well as his satisfaction) via a good sound spanking--the traditional patriarchal male dominance being thus expressed.
These scenes apparently appeal to many female readers (including non-spankophile ones) who prefer the old-style maledom/femsub romantic relationship, although my darling wife, who's basically vanilla, generally considers them slightly "abusive"--she has zero tolerance for physical discomfort and wouldn't personally consider a nonconsensual adult spanking as an act of affection or love.
"Different strokes," onviously... --C.K.