Nice to see that there others besides me who like the idea of spankings with some sort of clothing left in place, whether some type of panties or whatever.
So often have run across discussions where someone insists that the only proper way to spank is with panties down. And the point of view where people say they hate thongs because they somehow detract from the mystery that is baring a bottom,the anticipation of seeing it uncovered.
I like the idea of women wearing thongs when they are spanked, but also all types of panties. In fact I came across the phrase "a good pantywarming " somewhere.
Spankings over panties, with them lowered first, or spankings that start over them and then finish bare-all are valid scenarios.
They can be thongs, bikini panties , full-coverage briefs(so-called "granny panties"),any of them.My story "Red for Renee" featured a spanking over the boy short style. And of course some may have read my stories where girls get spanked for having their thong panties showing. And of course for not wearing panties at all.
Lingerie spankings are a favorite of mine,as are swimsuit spankings. And I hope to someday write a story where a woman wearing a tennis dress gets spanked on the pants she wears underneath it(perhaps prior to being spanked with them pulled down). And of course one of the first I ever wrote, "A Bimbo Gets Her Booty Blistered" where a young lady has the misfortune to be wearing a pair of booty shorts that expose a generous amount of her asscheeks when she winds up on the wrong end of a paddle | 
