njrick:
perhaps in my case it's because the story isn't that good in anyone's estimation other than my own).
You know, I was thinking about that very thing, but from the other side. Some of my stories which I think are utter crap have attracted some comments, and some people even have them as favourites! I am thinking particularly of 'That Purifying Pain' which was one of my first efforts - it's rubbish, and I actually hesitated about submitting it to the Library at all. Purple prose and sentimental claptrap!
I have also been thinking about 'best' work again, and that's also difficult. Some of my stories are period pieces, some contemporary; some are serious, some light-hearted, some fantasy, sci-fi, fan-fic ... it depends on my mood at the time.
It's the same when I want to watch a film. Am I in the mood for 'Hamlet' or 'Toy Story', 'The Shawshank Redemption' or 'Mary Poppins'? It all depends.
kdpierre:
My best piece? "Montage" without question.
I wholeheartedly agree, kdpierre. I thought that a masterpiece. And if I didn't comment to that effect, I shall do so forthwith.
Edit: have now commented. I think I commented before, but on a forum thread, not on the story itself.