recruit:
I too thought that the challenge produced very good stories. But I am probably not the only one to be left reflecting, not for the first time, that my own personal preferences are not necessarily shared by others. None of the seven stories I liked the best made it into the top six overall.
I make the point not to disparage the winners (and most of them were close behind in my ranking) but by way of congratulating those contestants who may be feeling a little deflated after seeing the results. Just because some people did not rank your efforts as high as others does not mean that you were unappreciated. Thank you.
Hi recruit
I know where you're coming from and I think it important to approach the Challenges as just a bit of collaborative fun ... as an opportunity to write (and read) on a theme you perhaps wouldn't typically consider. It would be impossible for us to give guidelines for voting, because we have no way of enforcing such. So it's best not to regard the Challenges as an actual competition with winners and losers. I absolutely agree with you that participating authors should not feel deflated because their efforts weren't ranked as high as others.
There were some real gems in this challenge, so thanks to everyone who participated, congrats to the top six, and free virtual drinks all round. (mine's a single malt btw)
